A nation's debt to Joe Wilson
The flap over Joe Wilson- a white Southerner- calling President Barack Obama- an African-American Northerner- a liar on national television in one of the very centers of American democracy has threatened to derail the national conversation on health care reform once again. But the nation actually owes Joe Wilson a debt, because he has ripped open the scabs covering the wounds of racism that continue to make our country bleed.
The election of Barack Obama to the Presidency allowed many Americans to pretend that the wounds of racism are healing or, indeed, even healed. But watching the news and even the daily interactions between people of different races show that those wounds remain very deep and are freshly cut every day.
I've never met Joe Wilson. Maybe he isn't a racist himself. Maybe he's just another disgruntled Republican bitter and angry that the promised permanent conservative majority promised by Karl Rove turned out to be a lie because Rove misoverestimated the American tolerance for incompetent and ineffective government. In any event, Wilson's words revealed the lie underpinning the Republican Party's pretense to moral superiority and exclusive claim to patriotism which they have been selling particularly since 1980. Ronald Reagan, if he could come back and have a look at these latter days of the GOP, would probably not even recognize this current collection of misanthropes as Republicans.
Wilson's few words and subsequent unwise intransigence showed the depth of the disrespect which has been accorded the first African-American President. Other Presidents have been met with grumbling when addressing Congress, but none have had "you lie!" shouted at them (even when it turned out thatthey had lied). Protesters bringing guns to places where the President was speaking "to exercise their Constitutional right to bear arms" is nothing more than an effort at intimidation in order to keep the uppity in their places. It worked in Mississippi and Alabama and throughout the South for a long, long weary time. Why not again? Protesters shouting for Obama's death are little different than the exultant accessories to murder clustered about the bodies of tortured and hanged black men slung from trees, grinning at the cameras recording their sins.
It is possible and even necessary for the Republicans to bring to the discussion strong criticism of Obama's and the Democrats' health care reform ideas. This is how laws are improved and strengthened in the crucible of debate. Racism- however veneered- disrespect and bitterness undermine the ideals of our republic like the worm in the bud. They are a cancer in the guts of the nation and, if not exposed and rooted out, these things will destroy us.
"They say that patriotism is the last refuge to which a scoundrel clings," sang Bob Dylan. Joe Wilson has exposed the bitterness, disrespect, false patriotism that dogs the Republican Party and the broader racism that still plagues our nation. These are more insidious threats to freedom than was ever seen from the handful of Communists of the Red Scare of the 50s. For bringing this into sharp focus, we owe Joe wilson a debt of gratitude.
The election of Barack Obama to the Presidency allowed many Americans to pretend that the wounds of racism are healing or, indeed, even healed. But watching the news and even the daily interactions between people of different races show that those wounds remain very deep and are freshly cut every day.
I've never met Joe Wilson. Maybe he isn't a racist himself. Maybe he's just another disgruntled Republican bitter and angry that the promised permanent conservative majority promised by Karl Rove turned out to be a lie because Rove misoverestimated the American tolerance for incompetent and ineffective government. In any event, Wilson's words revealed the lie underpinning the Republican Party's pretense to moral superiority and exclusive claim to patriotism which they have been selling particularly since 1980. Ronald Reagan, if he could come back and have a look at these latter days of the GOP, would probably not even recognize this current collection of misanthropes as Republicans.
Wilson's few words and subsequent unwise intransigence showed the depth of the disrespect which has been accorded the first African-American President. Other Presidents have been met with grumbling when addressing Congress, but none have had "you lie!" shouted at them (even when it turned out thatthey had lied). Protesters bringing guns to places where the President was speaking "to exercise their Constitutional right to bear arms" is nothing more than an effort at intimidation in order to keep the uppity in their places. It worked in Mississippi and Alabama and throughout the South for a long, long weary time. Why not again? Protesters shouting for Obama's death are little different than the exultant accessories to murder clustered about the bodies of tortured and hanged black men slung from trees, grinning at the cameras recording their sins.
It is possible and even necessary for the Republicans to bring to the discussion strong criticism of Obama's and the Democrats' health care reform ideas. This is how laws are improved and strengthened in the crucible of debate. Racism- however veneered- disrespect and bitterness undermine the ideals of our republic like the worm in the bud. They are a cancer in the guts of the nation and, if not exposed and rooted out, these things will destroy us.
"They say that patriotism is the last refuge to which a scoundrel clings," sang Bob Dylan. Joe Wilson has exposed the bitterness, disrespect, false patriotism that dogs the Republican Party and the broader racism that still plagues our nation. These are more insidious threats to freedom than was ever seen from the handful of Communists of the Red Scare of the 50s. For bringing this into sharp focus, we owe Joe wilson a debt of gratitude.

